The Lady Speaks

Random Thoughts

Two things running through my head this morning:

First up: the Obama gaffe, non-gaffe, truth-telling, or whatever it’s being called now.

It’s been rather disheartening this weekend to see so many left-wing blogs telling me, “It’s true! Small-town rural people are just racist, homophobic, xenophobic ignorants who turn to their guns or their gods rather than voting for someone who just wants to help them.”

Or, even more fun, the “if you’re not bitter, you’re not paying attention and aren’t doing enough” group.

Spare me.

Spin it how you want. Tell me his “inflection” in the video makes a difference. Tell me all about how we white, rural, working-class, voters do vote against our own interests. It doesn’t change my opinion of what he said.

Yes, I did read the entire statement, not just the paragraph posted in Obama Insults Pennsylvanians. And I read it again. And yes, I still believe he was, in effect, calling us low-class white trash who won’t vote for him because we’re too bitter about our economic status to vote for anyone who isn’t whiter than snow and doesn’t run on a “Guns, Gods, and Gays” platform.

I still believe that he was trying to explain to a bunch of rich donors just why he wasn’t doing as well as expected here, and his explanation to them is, “See these blue-collar folks are just too bitter and too dumb to understand that I’m all about Change and Hope© and they seem to actually want policies and positions and information. They don’t understand, because they’re dumb, rural, white trash, that I’m all about Change and Hope© and part of that is not saying anything that isn’t about Change and Hope©.”

But, apparently, to say so – to believe that this candidate insulted my state and my fellow Pennsylvanians – is also a white trash, homo- and xenophobic, racist belief.


I have to say I feel a little less welcome in a few of my favorite blogs today, after reading all the “It’s true and people who are insulted are just too dumb and too bitter to understand it” comments from people who do not live in rural Pennsylvania.

Gee, thanks, for helping me see the light. It’s good to know just how many blogs and their commenters actually believe they are better than those of us living in small-town America because they’re more “enlightened,” more “sophisticated,” or just plain smarter than we bigoted trash.

I should point out that in 2000, PA was one of only 20 states (plus DC) that went for Gore. In 2004, we were one of only 19 states (plus DC) that went for Kerry.

Second: the Bush-approved-torture non-flap:

Yep, I am well aware of what happened Friday, that our President – a man who stood before us twice and vowed to “preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States” – admitted that he approved torture.

And, I am well aware that the MSM has more or less ignored the same in order to cover the “blow to the Obama campaign.”

Why haven’t I said anything? Well, for one, because there are far smarter people who know far more about this who have already said everything. Short of cribbing all of Emptywheel’s posts on the subject, what I have to say on it amounts to this:

“Son of a bitch! He admitted, on television, that his legal team created justifications for torture, that members of his Cabinet (Cheney, Ashcroft, Rice, etc) knew and approved of said tortures, that he knew and approved said tortures, that human beings were tortured as a result — in contravention of the Geneva Convention and American law.

There is now absolutely zero doubt that he, members of his Cabinet, and his legal eagles are as guilty of crimes against humanity as any Nazi prosecuted at Nuremberg.

And the response from America was… *crickets*

The fucking media ignores it because Obama can’t keep his foot from his mouth.

Heckova job, BushCo!”

That is my response.

I could have made a post of it but, as always, Digby says it better:

I thought I was long past the point of being shocked at anything the Bush administration did. They suspended the constitution after 9/11 and set forth a series of legal opinions that said the president can do anything he deems necessary to “protect the country.” Once you truly absorb that fact, it’s hard to be emotionally affected by anything else you learn.

But I was wrong. This shocks me. The president of the United States casually admits on television that he approved of his national security team personally deciding which specific torture techniques should be used against prisoners:


The vice president, national security advisor and members of the president’s cabinet sat around the white house “choreographing” the torture and the president approved it. I have to say that even in my most vivid imaginings about this torture scheme it didn’t occur to me that the highest levels of the cabinet were personally involved (except Cheney and Rumsfeld, of course) much less that we would reach a point where the president of the United States would shrug his shoulders and say he approved.


April 13, 2008 - Posted by | Uncategorized


  1. Pa…. you are welcome at our blog any ole time your heart desires! I thank you for this post about Obama. Brings it into a new light for me. Hope all’s good in your world! How’s that ebay biz doing? Hope it’s becoming prosperous for you!! 🙂

    Comment by QG | April 13, 2008 | Reply

  2. I love stopping by BH. You guys have some of the best links!

    Life’s a going. I’m working on something new these days, since Ebay’s decided it’s more interested in earning profits at the expense of sellers.

    Comment by PA_Lady | April 13, 2008 | Reply

  3. This is know, and I know it beyond a doubt. I, being a lifelong, small town PA. citizen, was offended. He is as good with “code” as Bill Clinton, supposedly was in the south.
    Only, this was code for “ignorant, hillbilly, white trash.”
    I didn’t appreciate it.
    I listened to his apology. I listened to his inflection. I listened.
    I am sure of what he said, I am sure of what I heard.
    He is suppose to be the candidate of words, therefore, he knew what he was saying, and to whom he was speaking. What he did not seem to recognize was, that it would become public knowledge.
    He does not deserve to win PA. He does not deserve to win the nomination. He is far too G.O.P. for my blood.
    As some of his supporters keep telling me, the truth hurts.
    This truth will hurt him, and he has only himself to blame.

    Comment by Mom | April 13, 2008 | Reply

  4. Hi PA, you beautiful Typical White Bitter Bitch Goddess Person you! I’ve been to Ohio and Indiana campaigning and have considered coming to PA too. Meanwhile here in Michigan I have partnered up with a lady out of Florida that started a petition to Seat Our Delegates, and a website. We created a new blog this week on this topic that we’ve been getting fixed up:

    I received your message from jeffrey and came on over. I was cleaning up my sidebar the other day purging misogynist Blozos, (shocking isn’t it, my blogrolls are rather small now) and popped in here but didn’t have a chance to say Hello that day. Please do contact me anytime.

    Comment by Shez | April 14, 2008 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: